I emailed the corporation asking for clarification but to this point no word again. For the price of this food items, the 1st ingredient truly shouldn't be broth. It seems like from what I am able to Obtain this variation occurred if they removed the carrageenan from your foodstuff. https://finnstfsc.ageeksblog.com/35582429/5-tips-about-ziwipeak-uae-you-can-use-today